TLF on Google
I really like reading The Technology Liberation Front, but they’re in serious disarray over Google’s bid to force the 700 MHz band open. The backstory, for those who haven’t been following it: the FCC is about to auction off the last major block of radio frequencies that will become available for ten years or so. They’re particularly delicious frequencies, too, able to penetrate buildings and carry lots of information. Google’s been lobbying the FCC, hoping that the agency will require some or all of the winning licensees to keep their networks open: they’d have to let new services and devices connect instead of getting to pick who connects and what services they offer, the way today’s cellphone companies do.
This has thrown TLF into a tizzy. They’ve responded by providing hefty helpings of hand-wringing, ludicrous potshots, and, yes, some actually reasonable analyses of the situation.
It’s easy to see why they’re going nuts over this: their no-regulation ethos naturally favors big companies throwing their weight around. It’s the market working! But Google is also a big company. And it’s also throwing its weight around. Except this time, the weight is being thrown in the direction favored by those of us who want more regulation — the net neutrality cranks, communists and starry-eyed idealists. It’s a very confusing situation for market triumphalists, and it undercuts a whole class of “let ‘em play ball” arguments.
Consequently we get posts like this one, which is wrong in a number of ways: